Amana Digital USA +1 (781) 813-9622 Request a Free Consultation

How-to guide

Yelp or Google: where should a Boston small business focus?

By the Amana Digital USA teamPublished Updated 5 min read

For most Boston small businesses, Google comes first: your Google Business Profile shows up on Google Search and Maps when people look for what you do nearby, and it is where most customers read reviews and get directions. Yelp still matters, especially for restaurants, cafés and some home services, so claim your Yelp page, keep it accurate and reply to reviews there too. The main difference: you can ask customers for Google reviews, but Yelp asks businesses not to solicit reviews. Amana Digital USA manages Google Business Profiles in Greater Boston from $99 per month and keeps your other listings consistent.

Key points

  • Google Business Profile first: Search, Maps, directions, reviews.
  • Claim and complete your Yelp page too, especially for restaurants and services.
  • Ask for Google reviews; do not ask for Yelp reviews (Yelp discourages it).
  • Same name, address, phone and hours on both.
  • Reply to reviews on both platforms.
  • Google Business Profile management from $99/month.
Bakery owner holding a phone in her shop, next to a display of pastries

How the two differ

  • Google Business Profile appears on Google Search and Google Maps, and in many AI answers. It is free, and you can post updates, photos and offers.
  • Yelp is a review site and app with its own audience, strong for restaurants, cafés, bars and some home services. A business page is free; advertising is paid.

Reviews work differently

On Google, you can ask every customer for an honest review with your direct link, as long as you ask everyone and offer nothing in exchange. Yelp asks businesses not to request reviews from customers, and its software does not show every review: some appear as “not currently recommended”. So on Yelp, focus on a complete page, good service and polite replies, and let reviews come naturally. See how to get more Google reviews.

Where to put your time

  • Restaurants, cafés and bars: Google first, Yelp a close second; keep menus, hours and photos current on both.
  • Contractors and home services: Google first; keep Yelp accurate and reply to reviews.
  • Shops and professional services: Google first; a complete Yelp page is usually enough.

Keep both accurate

Inconsistent details confuse customers and search engines. See also getting on Apple Maps and Bing Places.

  • The same business name, address, phone and hours everywhere.
  • Holiday hours updated on both before the holiday.
  • Real, recent photos.
  • Replies to reviews, positive and negative, on both platforms.

What about Yelp ads?

Yelp sells advertising to appear higher in its results. Like any ad, it is worth testing only with a clear goal and a way to measure calls and requests. For most small businesses, a complete Google profile and local Google or Meta ads are easier to measure. See small business advertising ideas for Boston.

How we help

We manage your Google Business Profile (information, photos, weekly posts, replies to every review, monthly report) and keep your other listings, including Yelp, consistent with it. It starts from $99 per month. See Google Business Profile management or call Abdelouahab at +1 (781) 813-9622.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Is Google or Yelp more important for a small business?

For most local businesses, Google: it shows up on Search and Maps when people look nearby. Yelp still matters, especially for restaurants and some services, so keep it accurate.

Can I ask customers for Yelp reviews?

Yelp asks businesses not to solicit reviews. Ask for Google reviews instead, and keep your Yelp page complete.

Why are some of my Yelp reviews hidden?

Yelp’s software shows some reviews as “not currently recommended”. It is Yelp’s own system; focus on good service and a complete page.

Should I pay for Yelp ads?

Only with a clear goal and a way to measure calls and requests. Start with your Google profile and measurable local ads.

Can you manage our Google and Yelp profiles?

We manage your Google Business Profile from $99 per month and keep your other listings, including Yelp, consistent with it.

Need help with your Boston business?

Call Abdelouahab at +1 (781) 813-9622 or send us a message: free consultation and written quote.

CallFree Consultation